Live Help

Log Home Products


Ask An Expert

Newsletter


Your Cart

Cart is Empty
 
View Cart
Order History

Online Payment Service

Oil vs. Water Based Stains

First, let’s clear up one misconception: there are actually 3 different types of stains, not just oil- and water-based. Below is a brief overview of the types and their pros and cons. Sashco always recommends using a stain with some sort of film-forming property to it, as the film is where the majority of the UV protection is derived. And, as is usually the case, the higher-quality the raw materials, the greater the longevity and better long-term appearance of the product.

SURFACE STAINS: water-based or water-oil emulsions. They penetrate only into the first layer of wood cells. (Sashco’s Capture / Cascade system is a surface stain)

Pros: Environmentally friendly; low odor; water clean-up; good water-repellancy; compatible with caulk and chinking; dries fast, excellent UV protection and longevity out of better brands

Cons: Some brands dry hard and rigid, leading to flaking or peeling; back brushing required; weather conditions must be warm for proper drying and film formation; lower-quality resins fall apart quickly with UV exposure

SHALLOW PENETRATING STAINS: oil-based or water-oil emulsions. They penetrate 1-4 cell layers deep. (Sashco’s Transformation and High Sierra stains are both shallow penetrating stains)

Pros: Good water-repellancy; can be environmentally friendly; excellent water-repellancy; excellent UV protection and longevity out of better brands; most brands compatible with caulks and chinking; more “forgiving” when applied in less-than-ideal weather

Cons: sometimes slower dry time; film-forming, which can lead to peeling or flaking when proper prep is not done; solvent clean-up; resins used can dry hard and rigid

DEEP PENETRATING STAINS: all oil-based. They penetrate at least 3-4 cells deep, often as much as ½” deep. (No Sashco products are deep penetrating stains)

Pros: Good initial water-repellancy; little to no flaking or peeling since no film is left on the surface; easily re-coated; great for decks and shingles

Cons: Not compatible with most all caulk and chinking; minimal UV protection; leaves oily residue on surface; picks up dirt easily; slippery long after application; solvent clean-up; does not last long (especially on log homes); darkens significantly over time.